Episode Summary
In this episode of PowerPod, host Jamie Bernthal-Hooker is joined by Dan Wiseman to assess what the US midterm results, with Democrats taking control of both the House and Senate, mean for offshore wind under a still-hostile Republican president.
They map the recent landscape of executive actions, including stop-work orders, paused leases and payments to developers to walk away from projects, and the court challenges that have already overturned several of those decisions. With Democrats now holding the committee gavel and subpoena power, the conversation explores how increased oversight, demands for transparency on taxpayer-funded buyouts, and control of the purse strings could make future interference harder and more accountable. Dan and Jamie also discuss pending bills aimed at nullifying earlier freezes, the realistic limits of any “rewind,” and the potential for bipartisan progress on permitting reform, ports and jobs.
Intro (00:00):
Welcome to PowerPod, the renewable energy podcast from TGS 4C, a leading provider of offshore wind intelligence. In each episode, we explore the key developments shaping the offshore wind market and bring clarity to the biggest trends shaping the industry and the wider energy transition.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (00:10):
Welcome to PowerPod, with me or blast from the past, Jamie Bernthal-Hooker. So today, the US midterm elections have resulted in decisive wins for the Democrats, taking control of both the Senate and the House. The incumbent Republican president remains… hostile to offshore wind? Which hasn't gone undiscussed on PowerPod. But what do the midterms mean for this technology?
Are we seeing a gear shift or just a vibe shift? Is the question no longer state support versus federal vetoes but something more complicated? Today our usual host Dan Wiseman is on the other side of the mic to talk about what's happened and what it means. Hi Dan.
Dan Wiseman (01:10):
Hi, it's weird to be on this side of the table for once, but thanks for having me on.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (01:20):
Thank you for coming. So, let's get right into it. First things first, this is obviously an important moment, but can you just map it out for us in terms of offshore wind? We saw market values for renewable developers jump immediately following the results. Ørsted, EDP, Engie and RWE. Is this a turning point or just a change?
Dan Wiseman (01:40):
I guess it's kind of a bit of both, really. So, I guess just first of all give a bit of context for people who kind of are unsure how US politics work. Obviously, the US government has three main branches. You have Congress who essentially make the laws, you've got the president and his agencies that carry them out, and then if there's any sort of disputes or arguments, you've got the courts who sort that side of things out.
Now, most of the big moves over the past year came from the executive branch, from presidential authority. They obviously, as we know, stopped some projects that were already approved thanks to Interior Department-issued stop-work orders and they either paused or reconsidered other projects and lease areas as well. We also saw in a few cases they just straight up paid developers to walk away from their leases, which was always kind of a worst-case scenario for the industry.
And the problem was like Congress didn't vote on any of that at all. The administration took these actions completely unchecked, which isn't really the way that it should go. And that's why people are saying that everything happened without Congress stepping in like they usually would do.
The one thing that actually did push back through all of these memorandums and executive orders were the courts. And that's just mainly because developers sued. You know, they saw them come through and they saw the massive hit to their bottom line, and they were rightfully angry at the approach that they were taking. And because of that we saw a lot of federal judges this year overturn the stop-work orders and allowed projects like CVOW, the Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind project to carry on with their construction.
We also saw several states led by New York suing the administration over the cancellation of leases up in the New York Bight, off the coast of New York and New Jersey. So, there's been a lot of fight-back already. But I guess from the Congress side of things, you know, they did do something. They introduced a budget law back last year which cut quite a fair amount of the tax credits that offshore wind projects can claim. So, I guess it's not a case that they were completely asleep at the wheel. They just looked after the money and it was always going in kind of one direction, you know.
But I guess now that the Democrats have taken, like you said, both the House and the Senate it changes the game quite a fair bit. During the next Congress Democrats will be running the committees, which are the groups that hold hearings and can demand documents from certain agencies, which is a big deal. I mean we saw the Department of the Interior tried to use national defense as an argument against wind farms where they were saying, we have to put stop-work orders on these wind farms because they're interfering with radar and national security.
And when developers were coming back and saying, well, hold on, you know, we have our entire approval documents, our COP, or construction and operations plan, where we already worked with the then-named Department of Defense to work around the issues they had with radar interference and we got the green light. And when the courts were asking for documents from the DOI, it was all this is classified. Or we don't have those documents to hand.
So now Democrats can demand those answers and if they're not given freely they've got the power of subpoena at this point which is a powerful thing. Cause not even the administration is above subpoenas. If they ask for a document, they have to be provided with that document. So, I guess I mean to answer your question, I kind of digress there a bit. I think it's becoming more a question of not who's asking the questions anymore, but it's who's got the muscle to make the answer to those questions stick. And whether it turns into a proper turning point depends on how they use that muscle. But I think we've seen over the years that Democrats have always been pro-offshore wind, especially in the coastal communities. There's always been very little pushback from the blue wave to push out renewable energy. So, I think there is a turning point. It's just a case of waiting to see what that turning point looks like.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (06:35):
Yeah, that makes sense. And I guess, how does... I saw recently a photo of a new hat on the president's desk, which didn't say M-A-G-A on it, it said V-E-T-O on it.
Dan Wiseman (06:52):
Yeah, so he's been quite vocal about this. Veto has been used a lot in his speeches. And I mean that it is a concern for Congress because the president, over many things and draft laws, has that power of veto. But Congress can force issues as well. So, like I was saying before, they need to know the reasons why and they can ask for the reasons why and there has to be a very good reason for him just to go up and veto it.
So, if it's a case if they put forward this one hundred percent offshore wind bill or law that they're looking to put in place and he vetoes it, they can just challenge that till the cows come home until eventually, you know, to maybe save a bit of face, not just for himself but for his party. He might just cave in and just let it go ahead because this is all bigger than Trump now. It's about the Republican Party and what's best for their future in the States.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (07:54):
I think 100% offshore wind might be a bit extreme for anyone. I think there's enough drama to keep us all as observers of the market in a job at the moment. I did read in the papers the other day, I read in The Guardian a line where they said that this may reduce further political interference and could bring fresh confidence to the US renewable energy industry. Do you think so?
Dan Wiseman (08:30):
Yeah, I agree. I mean, unfortunately they can't just hit rewind. You know, if the government signed a lease or they've paid a developer to give one of their leases up, that's going to be a headache to try to get overturned. I mean you're looking at striking new deals or looking for court rulings. So, I think the realistic aim really is just making these decisions a lot harder to carry out. Make them more expensive and make them more transparent to the public.
And I suppose Congress has a lot of tools to help them along their way as well. They've got a lot of oversight. Like I was saying, a committee chair can ask the administration for things like legal reasoning behind decisions. They can ask for things like the internal analysis and exactly what it's costing the taxpayers. Because that's a big thing. I mean, we already know that Democrats are really poking around the payments to the developers. The administration's paid close to $2 billion on deals with companies such as Total and Invenergy and RWE and the like. And you know, the Democrats can now double check those figures against official records to make sure that what we're reading on the press releases is exactly how much they were paying out.
And the reason why that's so important is for the reasons you've seen people talk about the cost of living and affordability in the states. That was one of the main pain points for the US over the last two years. And if the Democrats can use anything as leverage, I mean money's a good one. Because the money that was paid out to developers was all taxpayer money.
And if you make these actual figures known to the public then, you know, that's a good sign for Democrats moving forwards and really puts a hit on Republicans in terms of their power of authority in the future. And again, you know, if they're not forthcoming with those answers, you've got subpoenas. So, it's a case that there's no way that they can kind of get away with just not fiddling the books per se, but kind of not being as transparent as maybe they need to be, especially when you're dealing with taxpayer money.
Another thing that the Democrats have a hold of are the purse strings as well. And money is a big deal; you can't do anything without it in the administration. Congress decides where all that federal money goes and they can ask essentially what you need it for. So, it's kind of like when you're a kid and you're asking your parents for money for something that you want, but you don't necessarily have, you've got to get past that brick wall of your parents before they give you any money to buy the things that you want.
And you know, it's the same with Congress. If they feel that something isn't worth federal money, they can just stop it there and then. Which is hugely important, especially with some of the kind of bullish decisions that have come from the Republican Party in the past, especially with offshore wind. So that's I mean, in practice that's the strongest weapon they have, because the administration needs money to do anything and everything. And one of the major tools they have as well is being able to create laws. Which is a very I guess underrated one because, you know, they make laws every day.
Laws are passed all of the time, but they have a massive impact. I mean, we've got bills in the states going around like HR 1781 and S 837 which would declare those memorandums at the beginning of Trump's presidency about the freezes on leases null and void and it would overturn that. And it would block any sort of money from being used to put those sorts of actions in place. So, it would essentially kind of jump start offshore wind again but the problem with that is it must pass through both chambers and then it has to get signed off by the president. Which means that it will be very unlikely to get written into law as written. There's probably going to be a lot of changes to it. But what that does is it shows what the Democrats' stance is on things and it shows that they're willing to fight for it. And it puts them in a very good position to like essentially to haggle with a president to get maybe not what they want, but something very, very close to it.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (13:19):
Excellent, yeah. And I guess with laws, it's interesting because in a democracy that has these presidential cycles, of course, new laws can be written and can maybe change the playing field. We saw the Inflation Reduction Act under the previous regime and now this one, the Big Beautiful Bill and everything that followed.
Dan Wiseman (13:45):
Yeah, and it also shows how things can be reversed. Cause obviously like say we had the Inflation Reduction Act, which provided much needed tax credits to offshore wind farms because these are hugely expensive things and it took away a bit of that burden. And then the Senate just last year just like, right, okay, well you can have this bill, but it has to work within this time frame. Everything outside of that is not qualified. And that's what can happen this time as well. So, a lot of the laws and the bills that have come in that maybe anti-offshore wind can be adjusted to accommodate a more favorable future for developers moving forward, maybe not over the next couple of years, but maybe in the longer term.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (14:26):
Does this only last four or eight years until the next anti-wind regime comes in, because these are long-term decisions?
Dan Wiseman (14:37):
I think that's long term. Yeah. And I think that's the problem is just the vicissitudes of political differences, especially with renewables, I mean it's easy to get into the thought process of Republican bad, Democrat good for offshore wind and renewables, which isn't the case. I mean a lot of the renewable energy bills and framework was put in place during the Bush era and they were staunch Republicans. And even during this last presidential cycle, we've seen a lot of Democratic states who are very against renewables and offshore wind. So, you know, even though we may see another kind of Republican presidency in the future, doesn't necessarily mean that's the end for offshore wind targets. And if we do see a Democratic president in the future, that doesn't necessarily mean that there's going to be the full support like we had under the Biden-Harris administration. It's very individual in terms of the approach
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (15:38):
Yeah, and many of the states pursuing onshore and offshore wind are, you know, deeply Republican states, so it doesn't necessarily map onto any particular side of the political spectrum or political parties. It is, as you say, a very individual thing. And perhaps future build-out is a red herring. We may be looking at this period of stability more in terms of the existing pipeline, the projects in the works.
Dan Wiseman (16:08):
Yes. I think there will be a lot of developers kind of holding their breath at the moment, just waiting for a potential sigh of relief to come January. Cause although everything has happened now, we know the Democrats are coming in, we still have to wait till January before they actually take office. And things start to change, but they're already starting to draft legislation and regulations. So, I think if things like the bills that they're looking to put in place and the legislation that they're looking to put in place comes through, I think we'll see a lot more stability for the consented projects that we have. I think we'll see a lot less kind of fear from developers and investors about the future of offshore wind. It won't pick back up the way that it did, for sure. But it will certainly be a better atmosphere in terms of certainty about things.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (17:07):
Brilliant. Looking at transmission and permitting and some of the areas where detail becomes important, do you see the parties working together?
Dan Wiseman (17:22):
Yeah, I mean I guess the easiest bit of common ground between the two parties is permitting reform and that's been a big thing. Not just for offshore wind but for the energy sector and the industrial sector as well and loads of people on both sides think that the permitting process, specifically for energy projects, is very slow and very unpredictable. So obviously there's a bit of agreement there which is nice. We did see Senate negotiators put out a bipartisan bill earlier this year, back in September, called the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. And the big idea of that is kind of permit certainty.
Which means that basically once an approval's been given, it's very hard to kind of yank that away from developers or make any sort of amendments to it. So, it gives developers that little bit of protection, I suppose, which is what they need, especially nowadays when you know you can invest billions of dollars into your project and then things change. So, kind of having that certainty and having that protection under a law, is super helpful. And because it covers so many projects onshore, nuclear, solar, offshore wind is kind of safe because it has that broad spectrum of projects that, you know, it's not solely for offshore wind, so it becomes a lot more plausible for them to actually win through it.
I think other things have I guess like a wider approval as well between the parties. Mainly things like ports and money for ports, which are big for offshore wind because it means they can develop ports to handle things like turbine blades and towers. It also helps the non-offshore-wind-focused states because you look at manufacturing and industrial scale as well. So, they share kind of a common ground on money for ports, and things like training and job opportunities as well, which everybody is big on.
It's an easy sell when you're saying, Look, all this money that we're putting into this sector is going to put people into work and help provide for their families, which you know is again like I was saying before, a big pain point over the last couple of years with the cost of living. But like you were saying with transmission, that's where it gets a bit trickier. You know, when you're looking at these massive power lines to bring all that energy on shore, it's a case of whether this bill, the affordability bill, how that determines where the share is of that transmission between projects and ultimately who foots the bill cause, you know, they're not cheap.
I mean we've gone over analysis of our cables in our latest report, over the cost of cables. Shameless plug there for our cable report. But I think that's where things are going to get heated and I think that's when the shouting's going to start between the two parties is the cost of things. But kind of this new Congress might change the maths on that a little bit. Democrats may want stronger guarantees that future administrations can't come back and reverse everything like they've started to do at the beginning of Trump's term.
And Republicans on the other side might want to try to lock in a deal before the new Congress takes over and it's going to come down to whichever of those pressures wins. Really, and that's going to decide whether this bill actually comes together, but I think at this point nobody really knows, but with there being so much common ground and very few contesting points, I think it's a positive move forward. Especially on a bipartisan scale for sure.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (21:30):
And it's nice to hear that positivity coming from the market sometimes. It's good to see that there's still some ambition and there's things being put into motion, which is really key. Do you think it's enough yet? And is there still time to attract investors? What are you hearing from investors and lenders right now?
Dan Wiseman (21:47):
You really talked up the positivity bit. The investors are properly nervous at this point, and rightfully so. I mean, from an analysis standpoint, there's not a massively positive outlook on offshore wind, especially in the US. And this is purely down to all of the policy whiplash. It really is knocking investor confidence, especially in the offshore sector because these are hugely expensive projects. And when you have states looking at things like floating wind, which is a largely untested technology, you know, it's very young in its stages of build out, the prices just keep going up and up.
So, for an investor or kind of lenders or banks that are giving the money, it's not just that the rules change, it's the fact that the rules can change at any point, regardless of how much money that you've put into these projects. So, you could be billions of dollars deep into a project and one small change to policy or one small change to law can completely upend your investment and leave you at a point where we saw with Total or Invenergy, where they couldn't afford it. I mean we saw with the Beacon Wind as well off the coast of Massachusetts and New York. They had progress stopped through one of the stop-work orders back at the end of 2025 and JIRA just walked away from offshore wind altogether in the US. Because that's how things looked then.
They have gotten better, things have gotten better, especially when developers are constantly in the courts arguing their piece and we're seeing federal judges take the side of offshore wind, which has been really refreshing to see because usually when you have a sitting party in the White House, everything tends to go that way. So the fact that we've had these impartial judges kind of go the way of offshore wind has been a big boon to offshore wind cause it just means that that light hasn't quite gone out.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (24:07):
And we had a construction milestone recently with a commissioning wind farm.
Dan Wiseman (24:18):
We did. Well, two. It's two. We had Revolution Wind, which fully commissioned in October according to Ørsted's first nine-month report. And we have reports of Vineyard Wind reaching commission as well. So, this is a big deal. I mean CVOW, I think the last time I read their update they said that they're around 80 percent overall into it. So, things are really chugging along with the projects that are under construction.
But it's like I said the rising costs that lenders are going to be looking at, policy uncertainty and just general financing trouble that's going to be the hurdles that they have to encounter and I mean other companies that have taken government checks to get out of their leases, you know, this already shows how knocked investors' confidence is. And I mean the forecasts looking into the future as well, they're relatively gloomy-ish, I suppose. Cause we're unlikely to see kind of a lot more activity in construction, for some time. Unless there's like a massive change. There has to be like some sort of drastic policy change for things to kind of pick back up. But over the next sort of decade it's going to be very slow and it's going to be very dependent on what happens in the courts and in the White House for that to change.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (25:42):
Yeah, that 30 gigawatts by 2030 target feels a long time ago.
Dan Wiseman (25:47):
Yeah, it certainly does. And I think that's a pipe dream now, the 30 gigawatts, that's a very, very long way away. But I mean hopefully this midterm election can help. But obviously we're not going to be seeing miracles overnight. Because obviously the banks and the lenders that finance these projects they want protection for the permits that are already in place before they start looking at investing in new ones. So, a changing Congress doesn't guarantee that on its own, but what it can guarantee is pushing for these policy protection bills, which will really help and it will give investors an idea that, you know, we can put capital into this because we know once it's permitted is relatively safe.
I mean it's not going to be a hundred percent safe because literally anything can happen. But there's a lot more protection than they would have had before. So, I think that's what investors will be watching. They'll be watching to see if this bill passes and I think if it does, touch wood, it does. I think we're going to see a lot of financial movement in the offshore wind sector for sure.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (27:02):
And what will you be looking out for?
Dan Wiseman (27:06):
The permitting bill I think will be the main thing that I'll be looking at, because I mean that dictates everything. And it's just watching to see if the Democrats feel that the bipartisan text is good enough. Or if there's going to be any pushback from the Republican side of things. And just to see if there's going to be any protection against kind of future reversals. I think that's the biggest thing. Just to make sure that something's in place that if kind of a party not focused on offshore wind or not keen on offshore wind is in place over the next term, that there are still measures in place that will stop what has happened over the last two years from happening again.
I think the second thing; it’s going to be seeing who heads the committees. Because dependent on who gets the energy and the environment gavels, really depends on how hard all these policies are going to bite. Cause if you get the wrong people in, they may not be super focused on this sector specifically. They may be pro renewables, but kind of offshore wind because of its stature in the grand scheme of renewables might not get the attraction that it needs.
But if you have someone super focused on renewables and super focused on all of them as a blanket concern, then you know that's going to be really positive. So, I think that's going to be really interesting to see who gets those seats. And I think another thing will be the transparency that comes with this change of Congress. Because obviously we're going to be seeing a lot of the documents that we didn't see in the courthouses and in the press releases. So, we're going to see things like the receipts from the lease buyouts. We're going to see the documents that the DOI provided courts to try to get offshore wind to stop. We're going to see a lot of the reasoning behind the stop-work orders as well.
So, it's going to be interesting. I mean, it doesn't make any difference to what happens from now, but it's going to be interesting to see how they did it. And how they managed to circumvent the law. You know, and in due process when it comes through to kind of just stopping things without congressional oversight and without going through the courts. So, I think that transparency is going to be quite interesting to keep an eye on for sure. And hopefully during a lot of these hearings, we're going to see a lot more than just government bodies and developers. Hopefully we're going to see kind of communities from offshore wind states, we'll see fishermen and stuff like that. So, it's going to be nice to hopefully have some more representation from all parties affected with renewable energies.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (29:57):
Get the conversation going again, really.
Dan Wiseman (29:38):
Having that chat. That's it. I mean because they've had these conversations before and it's felt like although it's very easy to think that offshore wind in the US has just stopped, it's just been on this weird hiatus in terms of development anyway. Like we were saying, we've seen some wind farms built and commissioned and up and raring to go and providing power into their communities. So, it's time to pick those conversations back up and start planning for the future because this is a very good opportunity with Democrats in both chambers to start laying the groundwork for when it can pick back up.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (30:48):
And I think that's a lovely note to wrap up on. So, thank you for joining me, Dan. Thank you for helping to Make Podcasts Great Again.
Dan Wiseman (31:00):
I wouldn't phrase it like that, but no, that's no problem. Thanks for sitting here with me instead of me just yammering to myself about the states.
Jamie Bernthal-Hooker (31:10):
It's a pleasure. Join us again for the next episode of PowerPod. Goodbye.
Host
Featured Guest

